SARAH PREUSCHL ANDERSON

Dynamic design thinker and creative leader, with 20 years in professional marketing CPG and nonprofit sectors. Proven track record as a catalyst for growth. Creative problem-solver. Motivated by collaborative influence. Known for transformative brand-building, insight-driven innovation mapping, effective creative, and on-target positioning. 

STRENGTHS

  • Insight-driven Brand Strategy

  • Creative Briefing & Direction

  • Unique Design and Copy Intuition 

  • Galvanizing Teams

  • Broad Commercial Experience (Direct-to-
    consumer, Retail Consumer, Not-for-Profit)

  • Full-funnel Operating Background

  • Strategic Planning

  • Vice President of Marketing   •  January 2024 –  June 2025
    Director of Marketing  •  2014 – 2023

    Oliver Winery is the 30th largest winery in the U.S., sold in 43 states with 90% of sales in national chains (eg. Walmart, Kroger, Target). Oliver is also a top U.S. wine tourism destination with a thriving
    e-commerce business. Following five consecutive years of double-digit growth, Oliver was acquired by NexPhase Capital in 2021.

    • Direct report to CEO and member of executive leadership team, reporting monthly to board.

    • Influenced a broad scope of work, from corporate strategy, budgeting, and media planning, to digital content strategy, brand creative, and marketing systems.

    • Increased capacity of lean in-house team through agencies, managing to maximize value.  

    KEY ACCOMPLISHMENTS

    • Brand Strategy: Created Oliver’s first-ever core values and brand standards—establishing a scalable strategic foundation.

    • Category Leadership in Sweet Wine: Defined breakthrough positioning that expanded reach beyond the heartland, fueling 2.7x revenue growth and doubling distribution.

    • Consumer Insight to Action: Led research and insights-to-strategy work with Nielsen, Ipsos, and Seed Strategy to guide brand decisions.

    • Innovation from Concept to Shelf: Spearheaded award-winning innovation pipeline. 2025 releases Cosmoberry and Dreamberry  named Progressive Grocer Best New Product.

    • Sustained Innovation Impact: 70% innovation success rate; high-margin launches like Blueberry Moscato and Porch Swing now drive 1/3 of total volume.

    • Brand Narrative & Earned Media: Built compelling brand storytelling and strategic PR partnerships—earning 2B+ national media impressions in 5 years.

    • Creative that Converts: Delivered top-tier results on lean budgets—May 2025 Meta campaign hit 29% conversion, 24.2 pt recall lift (3x CPG benchmarks).

    • Cross-Functional Alignment: Unified stakeholders to deliver annual consumer/shopper marketing and media plans that drove real-world activation.

    • Strategic Partnerships: Forged and negotiated key partnerships (e.g., NFL’s Indianapolis Colts, Skrewball) to elevate brand and drive retail programs.

    • Culture & Engagement Champion: Led internal engagement efforts, contributing to 4x “Best Places to Work in Indiana” honors.

  • Director of Marketing  •  2012-2014

    Nonprofit organization serving 500,000+ living Indiana University alumni, focused on building value
    in the  membership product and cultivating alumni as future donors.

    • Direct report to CEO and member of executive leadership team.

    • Award-winning 16-person team; Indianapolis and Bloomington campuses; ~1,500 annual projects.

    • Established annual operating plan and account management structure

    KEY ACCOMPLISHMENTS

    • Brand Architecture: Defined IU Alumni Association (IUAA) visual and verbal brand standards, forming foundation for university-wide visual design.

    • High-Impact Engagement: Created the “Put Your Stripes On” campaign, driving 1.2M+ organic impressions and an 84% lift in web traffic.

    • Acquisition & Retention Wins: Delivered nine straight months of membership growth with
      the integrated “All for You” campaign targeting high-LTV audiences.

    • Data-Driven Content Strategy: Improved average email open rates by 7% across 6M+ annual sends through strategic content and testing.

    • Foundational Market Research : Built and leveraged a proprietary 1,200-member IU Alumni Panel for ongoing insights and marketing optimization.

    Manager, Interactive Media   •  2011 – 2012

    Led 5-person team in digital marketing platforms (web/CMS, social media, email, CRM). Spearheaded redesign of IUAA's Webby-winning website. Launched brand and content strategy.

    Director, Constituent Publications & Web Communication  •  2010 – 2011

    Pioneered management of IUAA social media presence, email journeys, and web-based publications.

    Editor for Constituent Publications, IU Alumni Association  •  2008 – 2010

    Edited, designed, and coordinated production of 60+ annual publications. 

  • Marketing Writer/Editor & Project Management Consultant  •  2006 – 2008

    Authored content and marketing strategies that significantly improved U.S. News and World Report rankings. Retained to launch complete web redesign as leader of 14-person working group.

AWARDS & ACCOLADES

  • Progressive Grocer Best New Product • 2025
    PROGRESSIVE GROCER EDITOR’S PICKS
    Cosmoberry & Dreamberry for cutting-edge innovation in wine.

  • Great Lakes Emmy  • 2024, 2025
    NATAS - Central Great Lakes Chapter

    • 15- and 30-second 'Everyday Sommelier' commercial spot (2024, with Bayonet)

    • 6-minute 'Ready for Growth' brand storytelling video
      (2025, with Blueline Media)

  • Blue Chip Brand • 2022
    M SHANKEN COMMUNICATIONS: MARKET WATCH
    Best-performing beverage brands, five-year horizon.

  • Impact Hot Brand Award • 2019, 2020, 2021
    M SHANKEN COMMUNICATIONS: IMPACT DATABANK
    Fastest-growing brands in alcoholic beverage industry.

  • National Innovations in Employee Ownership Award • 2018
    NATIONAL CENTER FOR EMPLOYEE OWNERSHIP (NCEO)
    Execution, planning, and branding for Oliver Winery Field Day initiative.

  • Silver, ADDY Award • 2017
    AMERICAN ADVERTISING FEDERATION (AAF) INDIANA
    "How to Win at Pie Eating” online commercial creative concept & art direction.

Find more professional recognition & awards  

MARKETING EXPERTISE

  • Consumer Trend Review & Analysis (Nielsen, Spectra, IRI/Spins)

  • Microsoft Office Suite & Power BI Analytics

  • Adobe Creative Suite

  • CMS / CRM tools

  • Workflow Management (eg. Smartsheets, Monday.com)

  • Social Management (eg. Meta, Sprout Social, Hootsuite)

  • Privacy Compliance (eg. CANSPAM, GDPR, CCPA)

LEADERSHIP TRAINING

  • The Predictive Index® 

  • Clifton Strengths®

  • EQ-i 360

  • Trademark & Copyright Management

  • Financial Reporting & Metrics (e.g. EBITDA, Margin, COGS)

  • IU Management Training Series

  • Advisa Leadership Training Series

  • Stakeholder-Centered Executive Coach Certification, Marshall Goldsmith, 2014

She directs teams brilliantly—she is decisive, firm, and empathetic, and she leads her colleagues to do award-winning creative work.
— PEER LEADER & PROJECT PARTNER, Indiana University
Her mentoring sharpened my writing skills and transformed me into a thoughtful content strategist.
— DIRECT REPORT, Indiana University

REFERENCES & TESTIMONIALS

The kind of working relationships Sarah fosters provide an environment for trust and authenticity, which allows her to get the very best work out of her teams.
— PEER LEADER & PROJECT PARTNER, Oliver Winery
Sarah always provided clear direction and insight to guide her team with a steady hand, creating a highly-productive collaborative work environment.
— DIRECT REPORT, Oliver Winery
.. a consummate professional and an extraordinary leader. As a manager she has the ability to grow and develop individuals to bring out their strengths and turn raw talent into polished professionals that deliver results. She is a creative visionary with a passion for developing concept and brand and the ability to create a strategy for implementation and realization.
— PEER LEADER, Indiana University
She was genuinely open and curious about others’ opinions, and she seemed to take real pleasure in building on strategic ideas...
— DESIGN AGENCY PARTNER, Oliver Winery